1. Neil Young. There are no words for how much I detest this man’s voice. NOTHING gets me in a bad mood more than being subjected to his nasally whine. For Bret’s sake (because he thinks this guy is a musical god), I have tried to overcome my aversion. Nope. Can’t be done. Neil Young’s is one of the few human voices officially categorized as scree-scraw. Evidence submitted: Pick a song. Any song. Too bad, because he wrote some good lyrics.
2. Bon Jovi. Jon Bon Jovi has more talent in his nose hairs than most bands have in all their members put together. He has a marvelous voice, and — with sidekick Richie Sambora — has written a plethora of excellent songs, resulting in platinum albums for the group. He’s a fine actor, as well. Evidence submitted: An entire genre of music (”unplugged”) was born with Jon and Richie’s acoustic performance of “Wanted Dead Or Alive” at the 1989 MTV Music Awards. JBJ was nominated for both a Grammy and an Academy Award for his song “Blaze of Glory,” from Young Guns II (and he won the Golden Globe). Also, check out JBJ’s performances as the heroic chief engineer in U-571, and as the alcoholic wife abuser in Pay It Forward.
3. Joni Mitchell. Bret thinks this woman is the greatest female musician of all time. I’m sorry, but her voice is so shrill, it makes my teeth hurt (literally). Although I DO have a decent version of her doing “Stormy Weather.” But she’s no Etta James, that’s for sure. Evidence submitted: Three words: BRAND. NEW. KEY. Ouch.
4. Rod Stewart. I adore this man. Pretty much everything he’s done is in my musical library. Bret admits to liking “Gasoline Alley” and “Maggie May,” but detests all Rod’s other work. This is incomprehensible to me. Evidence submitted: “Reason To Believe,” one of the best songs ever done. Plus, compare any of Rod’s covers (”The First Cut Is The Deepest,” “This Old Heart Of Mine”) to the original versions, and hear the marvelous improvement.
5. Frank Sinatra. B-O-R-I-N-G. What good is a wonderful voice if your songs sound dull and lifeless? There is no heart in Sinatra’s music. He sounds so insincere — like he’s singing just to hear his own voice. If a song doesn’t make me feel something, I don’t want to hear it. Evidence submitted: Compare Sinatra’s version of any song with Tony Bennett’s version. You’ll hear what I mean, just as Bret did.
6. The Rolling Stones. Bret does NOT like them. At first, I thought he just didn’t like to look at them. Nope, he doesn’t like their music. He’ll actually ask me to turn it off. In fact, he’s not even familiar with some of their most famous songs! I was quite shocked. Evidence submitted: How can you not love “Sympathy For The Devil”? It’s a masterpiece! And “Satisfaction” is a genuine classic. What about “Start Me Up,” with its infamous line: “You’d make a dead man come…”? [Author's anecdote: I once had a guy sing that line to me at a party. Which would have been amusing except that: A. The song wasn't playing at the time, B. He was my husband's best friend, and C. My husband then knocked him flying into the swimming pool.]
7. John Lennon. Bret considers Lennon to have been a musical genius. Maybe so, but I still didn’t care much for either his voice or his lyrics, with a few notable exceptions (”You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away,” a killer song). I have always preferred Paul McCartney’s sweet, “silly love songs.” Evidence submitted: The incredibly irritating “Imagine,” which has inexplicably become a near-religious mantra to millions, generating exactly what it denigrates.
8. Van Halen. Bret thinks they are an overrated group of mediocre musicians with a damn good agent. I think — whether their frontman is Dave or Sammy — they have made a bunch of wonderful songs, and evolved with time. Has anybody ever had more fun playing guitar than Eddie Van Halen? Just look at his face in any of their videos — he’s got a grin like a kid with a new bike! Evidence submitted: Where to start? OK, with my personal favorite, “Finish What Ya Started” — an irresistable, instantly-recognizable guitar intro, slyly ambiguous words and Hagar’s pleading yowl. But there’s also “Running With The Devil,” “Jump” and don’t forget “Hot For Teacher”!!!
9. Paul Revere and The Raiders. These guys were musical jokes! Pure bubblegum buffoons. It amazes me that my musically-literate husband and in-laws hold them in such esteem. Did they never watch Where The Action Is ? Evidence submitted: “Cherokee Nation,” a silly stereotype-laden lament in which they cite the tomahawk and Bowie knife as part of the Cherokee “way of life.” Neither was ever used by any of the Five Civilized Tribes.
10. Donna Summer. She was the Queen of Disco, and I spent many an evening burning up the dance floor to her infectious tunes. Bret thinks they’re infectious all right — like Ebola (he loathes disco). Evidence submitted: Ask anyone to name five disco songs, and I guarantee at least one of them will be a Summer hit. But she didn’t do only disco! “The Woman In Me,” from her eponymous album, is one of the most sensually literate songs I’ve ever heard.
11.11. Yanni. I finished this list, then realized I’d left off the guy who should have been #1! There is no other artist that will make Bret leave the house faster than Yanni, with his New Age, electronically-enhanced piano melodies. They grate on Bret’s nerves like sandpaper. I, on the other hand, find them soothing and lovely. They make perfect background music for writing or reading, and are marvelous accompaniment for a bubble bath. Guess it must be a chick thing. Evidence submitted: “Winter Light,” an exquisite collection of evocative music that flows over you like liquid beauty. It was my first introduction to Yanni (at a Wiccan celebration of Yule), and is still my favorite.
[Author's footnote: No, these differences of opinion DO NOT create disharmony in our home. Music (of ANY kind) is like oxygen to Bret and me — if we're awake, it's on. And we enjoy a passionate debate about music, or anything else. Life would be dull indeed if we were all the same!]